You are here: Home

China Lawyer Blog - We answer your questions

China Lawyer blog

China Lawyer Blog


What to consider when selecting between China lawyer handling seocial security

Now that you have a list of possible China lawyers, you need to make a final selection. I have these suggestions. These are general rules, almost all of which have exceptions, except I guess the first two:

• Be careful when choosing a China lawyer you have never been able to work with.

• Talk to several lawyers before hiring one.

• Ask questions, and look around the office. Does it seem like a well run machine, or are people wandering around looking lost? Are people pleasant to you and to each other? Are they working hard, or chatting?

• Experience is important. I would want a lawyer with at least, say, 5 year’s experience as a Social Security lawyer.

• The lawyer should emphasize Social Security. I would want a lawyer whose practice was 70% or more Social Security law.

• Be sure you can get your lawyer by the throat. Be sure you can get the lawyer on the phone if you need to, in a couple of days if there is no emergency, and right away if there is. But if you think about it you will decide you want a lawyer who is busy. If there were two restaurants side by side, would you want to eat at the one with lots of cars in the parking lot, or the one with the empty lot?

• Talk to the staff. Ask who besides the China lawyer will be helping you. Meet that person, and size that person up. Make sure that the lawyer you are talking to is the one with the experience, and the one who will handle your case.


How to find a good China lawyer handling estate planning

Most people seem to be somewhat uncomfortable with the idea of seeing a China lawyer.  First, the task of finding one you like can seem daunting.  But even if you find a lawyer you like, it can be difficult to determine whether the lawyer is actually doing a good job.  The average person has little to go on by way of comparison of a lawyer’s work against any sort of standard.  After all, one cannot go around looking at other people’s wills or trusts to see if they stack up against the will or trust your lawyer is drawing up for your elder loved one, or for you.  So, how does one begin to look for a qualified China lawyer?


Unfortunately, law schools do not teach communication skills as a part of the standard curriculum.  One does not need to be good at "people skills" to pass the China bar examination.  A qualified lawyer can be very good at the technical aspects of legal work and terrible at relating to people.  By way of analogy, some physicians are really great technically, but have no "bedside manner".  Having practiced as a lawyer for the past twenty-nine years, dealing with hundreds of individuals, my perspective is that the client deserves certain basics if he/she is willing to pay an attorney for time, work, or legal representation.  One essential is that the prospective client deserves a chance to briefly meet with or at least, talk to the attorney without being charged for the attorney’s time, to simply see if it feels like a good fit.  There is no law which grants any consumer this right.  Rather, it is simply courtesy.  My perspective, which may not be shared by lawyer colleagues everywhere, is that if someone who doesn’t know me is willing to trust me enough to pay for my time, that person has a right to meet me and ask questions before writing a check. So, I recommend that you contact the lawyer you are considering asking for assistance, and interview the lawyer briefly.  If you like the tone and type of answers you get, go forward.  If you are put off by an abrupt manner, the lawyer seems to be in a hurry, or you are not comfortable with anything about the China lawyer, keep looking.


China anti commercial bribery system and lessons learned from GSK scandal

China anti commercial bribery system

China does not have specific anti-commercial bribery laws dealing with domestic business corruption and bribery. Instead, this is provided for under the PRC Anti-Unfair Competition Law (“AUCL”) and PRC Criminal Law, which applies to all Chinese citizens and any persons within China. Both laws also apply to all companies and institutions organized under China’s laws, which include Chinese domestic companies, Sino-foreign joint ventures, wholly foreign-owned enterprises, representative offices and even foreign companies doing unincorporated business in China.

The AUCL prohibits business operators from “giving bribes in the form of property or other means for the purpose of selling or purchasing products.” The PRC Criminal Law, however, criminalizes the act of “giving money or property to any employee of a company or enterprise or other entity for the purpose of seeking illegitimate benefits.” If an entity commits such a crime, it shall be fined, whilst a person who is directly in charge and other persons who are directly responsible for the crime could be sentenced to imprisonment or detention. The PRC Criminal Law also has specific provisions governing governs against bribery to government-related officials.


Basics of China Prenuptial Agreement

The Law Office of China Commercial Law Co., Guangdong works with couples that wish to establish the terms of a settlement agreement either before or after they are married-in the event that they later decide to divorce or legally separate.

The benefits of a prenuptial agreement are that although it costs you attorney's fees now; down the road if things don't go as planned you will save a lot of nerves and money on fees in case of separation or a divorce. It will reduce the number of times you will have to be in court (except issues related to children), because other issues have already been resolved in advance in writing. It will speed up settlement and reduce the risk exposure and publicity. If there is a great disparity in the couples existing net worth, pre-nup is the smart choice to prevent problems in the future.

Premarital Contracts Offer More Certainty

What if? It’s a question we ask when we buy insurance, knowing that we cannot control the future, but also knowing that we should be prepared. A prenuptial agreement offers more certainty in the eventuality that the marriage ends in divorce, separation or death.


China Lawyer Hourly Billing and Value Billing Practice

I have been having an ethics debate with another attorney. Our discussion revolves around this:

1.      I assert that it would be unethical for an attorney billing hourly
to bill (for example) three hours instead of one (when the time spent was one hour), on a project, when the time spent re-using (for example) a motion which was previously drafted for another client was one actual hour.
2.      Other attorney asserts that it is ethical to bill three hours for
that one hour of actual work because an earlier client paid for three hours to create the original motion, and it would be unethical to charge a later client less because an earlier client paid more.
a.       My response is that this is essentially double-billing, and that we
have an ethical obligation to use any usual means to reduce client billable hours, including using earlier motions, pleadings, and parts of briefs (appropriately reviewed and updated, of course) when possible.

I distinguish this from flat or "value" based fees and contingency fees, and look only at the case where the client is contracted on an hourly basis.

Another colleague responded:

Let me pass these examples by you:


Whether and how non-compete clause enforceable in China

As experienced China corporate lawyer, we frequently encounter the situation where clients inquire about non-compete clause and even independent non-compete contract.

Non-Competition provisions restrict individuals and organizations from providing services or engaging in businesses in certain markets and geographies for a period of time. The enforceability of these clauses varies from State to State. The examples are taken from agreements covering matters broader than just non-competition, such as employment agreements, acquisition agreements or license agreements.

On January 31, 2013, the Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China, China’s highest court, released Judicial Interpretation on Labor Disputes (IV) (“Interpretation IV”). The Court had published a draft of the Interpretation for public comments in June 2012. However, there are major differences between the final interpretation and the draft, which is intended to balance the interests of the employer and employee.Employers in China are under a statutory obligation to compensate employees for observing non-compete obligations after termination of the employment. Until recently, it was uncertain how much compensation the employer was required to pay. Some local regulations provided for indicative percentages, but most did not.


Different types of companies in China

As China corporate lawyer, we share following rules and regulation about China business organization laws with you. China’s Company Law recognizes two types of companies.

Limited Liability Company

This type of entity requires a minimum capital of RMB 30,000 with less than 50 shareholders.

The capital can be in the form of cash, industrial property or land use rights.

Company Limited by Shares

This type of entity is to be set up by promotion or share offer with a minimum share capital of RMB 5 million. For incorporation, no less than two promoters are required. Establishment by share offer is subject to the approval of China’s securities regulator.

Foreign Investment Entities

Foreign investors are allowed to set up the following types of business entities:

1. Cooperative Joint Venture (CJV)

A CJV has the option to register as a legal person with limited liability. The parties in a CJV have the flexibility of choosing whether to operate the enterprise as a limited liability company or to operate it as an unincorporated entity under which partners bear unlimited liability. The profits of a CJV are allowed to be shared by participants as specified in the joint venture contract, and not necessarily in proportion to their capital contribution. As a result, this type of venture is ideal when the foreign investor is only looking for a short-term project. After obtaining a fair or premium return on investment, the foreign investor returns the majority or full ownership of the enterprise to the Chinese partner.
•A cooperative venture does not require a new business licence if it is arranged in contractual form under the auspices of an existing joint venture enterprise.
•There are no expiry periods or limitations on the length of the venture. The contractual terms can be renewed at any time and for any extended period, subject to the approval of the government.
•Investment contributions from each party are not limited to financial capital but may also include non-financial assets such as intellectual property rights, buildings, materials or machinery.
•Transfer or withdrawal of investments is not subject to the approval of the government. Foreign investors can deploy their registered capital as they see fit.


China attorney-client privilege and lawyer professional conduct

I'm not familiar with the ethical rules that may be, but it seems to me a case could be made that the assistant is a part of that attorney's person as necessary for them to function in a professional capacity on par with others without a disability that impacts such functioning within a work context. The assistant is essentially a means of equalization for the attorney, allowing he or she to operate on a more level playing field. Another consideration is that it's likely in the client's best interest the attorney have all they need to perform well, especially at trial. A third thought on this, while nothing related to disability should come down to money, is that an assistant may also be in the attorney's employment, almost as the necessary part of the office that someone else who replied referred to a paralegal as. ic

There is well established case law  and rules that apply attorney-client privilege to legal staff in addition to the lawyer. So a lawyer plus assistants plus legal secretary plus law clerks, plus associate attorneys, plus general staff all come under the privilege which means the assistant does not need to leave every time a lawyer takes a call from a client.

An example is that when China finally clears my service dog and gives me an assistant because of my severe disabilities the assistant will stay with me all the time as with my wonderful dog who won't disclose any secrets.

When my law school professor was teaching law and ethics over 15 years for mental health professionals I had various test items requiring the students to identify if the situation was ethical or not. One example entailed two licensed MFTs consulting on a case in a crowded McDonalds while stuffing their faces with Quarter Pounders, large fries, extra large Coca Cola, dessert, etc.

Page 4 of 38
  • Goal

  • Fees

The law blog is running by a China lawyer working for a full-service law firm, offering practical, results-driven advice on employment law, divorce, company law, and other legal issues. Our goal is to manage these issues effectively so that our clients can focus on what they could do best.

China Lawyer Blog will charge you under your specific circumstances in the following styles:
(1) Hourly fee arrangements
(2) Contingency fee arrangements
(3) Flat fee arrangements
(4) Percentage fee arrangements

Learn More...


China Lawyer Blog China Lawyer Society

China Lawyer

I am a licensed China lawyer. Most clients are foreign nationals and companies. China Lawyer Blog have associates in Beijing, Shanghai, Tianjin, Guangzhou, Suzhou, Nanjing, Qingdao, Fuzhou, Hainan, Hefei, Wuhan, Xian, Changsha, Xiamen and Hangzhou. Learn More

Latest Comments


China law society award

Style of Service

This China Lawyer Blog is aiming at providing better knowledge and understanding of Chinese law for foreigners. Should you have any legal issue in China, do not hesitate to contact China Lawyer Blog for consultation. Preliminary consultation is free. Further legal service, however, will be charged in due rate and in due course.

You are welcomed to ask for a quotation pursuant to your specific circumstance.

About author

China Lawyer BLog AuthorPeter Zhu, an experienced China attorney licensed to practice law for more than ten years, the author of this China Lawyer blog, welcomes any enquiry or consultation related to Chinese law.